21% of people received an unwanted or unsuitable gift last Christmas (Which?, 2025). Clothing alone makes up 49% of everything returned or re-gifted afterwards, mostly because of size or fit rather than the thought behind it (survey data on UK gift returns). If you’re buying for the man in your life this year, the good news is the fix is simpler than it sounds.
Novelty gifts, socks on their own, and anything the recipient already owns are the reliable disappointments every year. What actually gets kept, worn and used is more predictable than you’d think, and it isn’t about spending more.
Here’s what the data actually says, on both sides of the wrapping paper.
Key Takeaways
- 21% of people got an unwanted or unsuitable gift last Christmas (Which?, 2025)
- Clothing tops the list of both cherished gifts (31%) and returned gifts (49%), and the difference usually comes down to fit
- Novelty gifts, duplicate items and socks alone are named most often as disappointing (CEWE survey, 2,000 UK adults)
- 40% of people rate a personalised gift, such as a photo book or something made specifically for them, above a generic one
What Do People Actually Value in a Gift?
Clothes top the list of cherished Christmas gifts at 31%, ahead of perfume and jewellery, both on 24% (UK consumer gift survey data). Personalised touches matter more than people admit. 40% of respondents rate a personalised gift, a photo book, something engraved, something chosen specifically for them, above a generic equivalent at the same price.
The common thread isn’t cost. It’s evidence that someone thought about them specifically, rather than picked something safe off a shelf on the way to the till.
What Ends Up Returned or Re-Gifted?
Clothing makes up 49% of everything returned or passed on after Christmas, more than any other category (UK gift returns survey data). Almost half of those returns, 45%, come down to the wrong size or fit, not the item itself. 47% of people who return something simply say they didn’t like it, and 39% already owned it.

Worth knowing: Clothing sits at both ends of the list, the most valued gift category and the most returned. That’s not a contradiction. It’s a sign the item was right in principle but wrong in the specifics, usually size, fit or style, which is exactly the part that a little research fixes.
What Should You Avoid Buying Him?
A 2025 CEWE survey of 2,000 UK adults found 73% had experienced disappointment from an unsatisfactory Christmas gift. Novelty items topped the list at 26%, followed by unwanted duplicates at 22%, socks on their own at 20%, and ugly Christmas jumpers at 11%. None of these are bad ideas dressed up wrong. They’re safe defaults, chosen because they’re easy to buy rather than because they’re actually wanted.
Socks specifically aren’t the problem. Socks bought as the entire gift, with nothing else, are what lands on the disappointing list year after year.
So What Actually Works?
Quality clothing in a confirmed size and fit outperforms almost everything else, precisely because it sits at the top of the wanted list when it’s right, and only falls into the returned pile when the size guess was wrong. A comfort-waist trouser, a good gilet, or footwear in a fitting he’s actually mentioned needing all land better than a generic tie or another gadget he’ll never plug in.
Personalisation doesn’t have to mean an engraved name. Choosing something for a specific reason he’s mentioned, colder mornings on the dog walk, a bad knee that needs proper support, a coat he’s been putting off replacing, does the same job as a monogram at a fraction of the effort.
What If You’re Not Sure of His Size?
Ask, or check a size label on something already in his wardrobe while he’s out. It feels less romantic than a surprise, but a wrong size guarantees exactly the kind of return that lands clothing at the top of the “returned” list despite being top of the “wanted” list too. If in doubt, a gift receipt or exchange-friendly purchase removes the risk entirely, and most people would rather have the right size a week late than the wrong size on the day.
Real-world note: Wide and extra-wide fittings are worth checking specifically if he’s mentioned tight shoes or swollen feet by the end of the day. It’s a detail that’s easy to miss and genuinely appreciated when it’s right.
Five Rules for Christmas Shopping That Actually Lands
- Confirm the size before you buy, not after. It’s the single biggest reason clothing gets returned.
- Avoid novelty as the only gift. It’s fine as an addition to something real, not as the main present.
- Buy for a specific reason, not a generic category. “Something for the cold mornings” beats “something for Dad” every time.
- Skip duplicates. If you’re not certain he doesn’t already own it, ask, or choose something else.
- Keep the receipt or buy from somewhere with easy exchanges. It turns a size guess from a risk into a formality.
Ready to Find Something He’ll Actually Wear?
Jolliman stocks the practical, well-fitted clothing that consistently tops the list of gifts people actually value, in sizes and fittings including wide and extra-wide. Browse the full range and buy with the size confirmed, not guessed.
Jolliman gifts range · Jolliman men’s clothing
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most disappointing Christmas gift, according to surveys?
Novelty gifts top the list at 26%, followed by duplicate items at 22% and socks given alone at 20% (CEWE survey, 2025). These aren’t inherently bad gifts. They’re just the defaults people reach for when they haven’t thought about the specific person.
Why does clothing get returned so often as a gift?
Mostly size and fit. 45% of returned gifts are the wrong size, and clothing makes up 49% of everything sent back or re-gifted after Christmas. It’s also the most valued gift category when the size is right, so the fix is confirming size before buying, not avoiding clothing altogether.
Are personalised gifts really worth the extra effort?
Yes. 40% of people rate a personalised gift above a generic equivalent. It doesn’t need to be engraved or monogrammed. Choosing something for a specific, mentioned reason does much the same job.
Is it better to ask what someone wants, or surprise them?
For clothing and footwear specifically, confirming size and fit in advance, even quietly, avoids the single most common reason gifts get returned. A well-chosen surprise still works well for smaller items where fit isn’t a factor.
What percentage of people get an unwanted Christmas gift?
21% of people received an unwanted or unsuitable gift last Christmas, according to Which? research from January 2025. Novelty items, duplicates and gifts that don’t match the recipient’s actual interests are the most common reasons cited.
In Summary
The data is fairly consistent every year. Clothing is both the most valued and the most returned gift category, and the difference comes down almost entirely to size and fit. Novelty items, duplicates and gifts with no specific reasoning behind them are the reliable disappointments.
Confirm the size, buy for a reason he’s actually mentioned, and keep the receipt just in case. It’s a simpler formula than it sounds, and it’s the difference between a gift that gets worn and one that gets quietly returned in January.




Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.