A good cardigan is the most useful thing in a man’s winter wardrobe. You can wear it over a shirt in the house, under a coat outdoors, and take it off when the room warms up. The question most men ask is whether to go for a zip or buttons. Here’s how to decide, and what else to look for.
Zip or button?
Our customers have already voted. Of all the cardigans ordered from us over the past year, nearly nine in ten had a zip. That doesn’t mean buttons are wrong, but it tells you something about what’s comfortable to live in.
Why a zip
- It’s quicker. One pull and you’re done. That counts when you’re heading out of the door.
- It’s easier on the fingers. If your hands are stiff in the morning, small buttons can be a real fiddle. A zip only needs one hand.
- You can fine-tune the warmth. Zip it to the neck outside and open it halfway by the fire.
Our Marl Knit Zip Front Cardigan has been a customer favourite for years, and it’s the one most men start with. If you’d like something a bit smarter, the Classic Full Zip Jacquard Cardigan has a concealed zip and a neat half-moon collar, so it looks tidy over a shirt and tie.
Why buttons
- It’s the traditional look. A button cardigan sits a little flatter and looks right with a collar and tie.
- Nothing to catch. There’s no zip pull to snag on a seat belt or a work bench.
If you like buttons but find small ones awkward, look for large buttons. Our Ribbed Knit Button Cardigan has a large button front made for easy fastening, in a soft 50% cotton, 50% acrylic blend. The Soft Touch Cable Knit Cardigan has a V-front and classic brown football buttons, if you’d like something with a bit of character.
How warm do you need it?
This is the question that matters more than the fastening. A plain knit is fine for indoors and mild days. If you feel the cold, or you’ll wear it outside, a fleece lining makes a big difference without making the cardigan look bulky.
- The Chenille Fleece Lined Zip Cardigan is soft on the outside and warm on the inside. It’s been our third best-selling cardigan this year.
- The Ripon Fleece-lined Cable Knit Cardigan has a high neck that zips right up to keep the wind off, plus ribbed cuffs and hem that hold the heat in.
- If you want buttons and warmth, the Yale Fleece Lined Button Cardigan looks like a smart navy knit from the outside, with the fleece hidden inside.
Getting the fit right
A cardigan is a layer, so it should fit over a shirt with a little room to spare. Fasten it and sit down. If it pulls across the stomach or the buttons gape, go up a size.
- The sleeves should reach your wrist bone, with ribbed cuffs that sit snugly without being tight.
- The hem should cover your belt, so no shirt shows when you reach up.
- Pockets are worth having. You’ll be surprised how often you use them for glasses, keys or a handkerchief.
Most of our cardigans come in sizes from M up to 2XL or 3XL. If you’re between sizes, go for the larger one. A slightly roomy cardigan looks relaxed, but a tight one always looks a size too small.
Looking after it
Always check the label first. As a rule, wash knitwear on a cool wool or delicate setting, then dry it flat on a towel rather than hanging it, so it keeps its shape. Avoid the tumble dryer unless the label says it’s fine, since heat is the quickest way to shrink a cardigan.
Find yours
Several of our cardigans are on a two-for offer at the moment, so it’s a good time to get one with a zip and one with buttons. If you’re not sure which size or style will suit, ring us on 0303 031 0310 (8am to 8pm, seven days a week) and we’ll help you choose.




Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.